Today, Kevin and I are excited to try Andy's Frozen Custard's latest offering: Cookie Butter Crunch. At $6.49 for a pint, it’s a reasonable price for premium frozen custard from an ice cream shop.
What Makes Cookie Butter Crunch Special?
Andy's Cookie Butter Crunch Concrete features real Biscoff cookie butter, crunchy Biscoff crumbles, and their signature vanilla frozen custard. This combination promises a buttery smooth texture with a crispy cookie crunch that takes the flavor to new heights.
First Impressions
We bought the custard directly from Andy’s, and because it's packed fresh, it’s not sealed like store-bought products. This ensures a freshly made treat with minimal handling by others.
Tasting Notes
The pint is generously filled, with a noticeable presence of cookies throughout. One standout feature is the ribbon of cookie butter that runs through the custard, adding a rich, flavorful layer to each bite. If you’re a fan of Biscoff cookies, this flavor is a must-try.
One of our viewers recommended this flavor, and as of our filming, it’s still available on Andy's website. While it’s uncertain how long this flavor will be around, it certainly deserves a permanent spot on the menu.
Texture and Flavor
While the custard tastes fantastic, we noticed that the cookie pieces aren’t crunchy. The texture is more custard-like, with the cookie butter ribbon providing a thicker, almost frozen peanut butter texture. Despite the lack of cookie crunch, the flavor is spot-on, replicating the taste of Biscoff cookies better than some cookies we've reviewed.
Availability and Customer Experience
One downside we’ve encountered with Andy's is their limited pint options. Despite having exciting new flavors, not all are available in pint sizes. They will serve these flavors in cups, shakes, or concretes but not in pints, which is something we find puzzling. Other ice cream shops, like Baskin Robbins, are more flexible, offering any flavor in pint form.
Final Thoughts
The Cookie Butter Crunch is excellent and worth the trip to Andy’s. If this flavor were available year-round, it would definitely tempt us to visit more frequently. However, the limited availability of pints can be a deterrent.
In conclusion, if you love cookie butter and frozen custard, head to Andy's and try the Cookie Butter Crunch while it lasts. It’s a delightful treat that captures the essence of Biscoff cookies perfectly.
No comments