This week, Kevin and I are reviewing Crumble Cookies' latest offerings: Double Fudge Brownie, Lemon Crinkle, Sugar, Strawberry Pretzel Pie, and Carrot Cake. Here's our in-depth review.
Pricing
First, let's discuss the pricing. A four-pack of these cookies costs $13.95, making it more economical to buy in bulk. Individually, a single cookie costs $4.28, but in a four-pack, the price drops to $3.49 each. Additionally, the carrot cake cookie is priced at $5.27, bringing our total to $19.22 before taxes.
Double Fudge Brownie
The Double Fudge Brownie cookie is a rich, brownie-like treat topped with chocolate glaze and brownie bites. It's thick, soft, and has a crunchy outer layer. The flavor is intensely chocolatey but not bitter, striking a balance between sweet and rich. It's comparable to a homemade brownie with a slightly thinner frosting layer.
Lemon Crinkle
Next, we tried the Lemon Crinkle cookie. This lemon-flavored cookie is rolled in sugar crystals and powdered sugar. It has a chewy center and a crisp exterior. The lemon flavor is subtle but noticeable, making it a refreshing option without being overly sweet.
Sugar Cookie
The Sugar Cookie is a traditional sugar cookie topped with vanilla frosting and decorated with candy eggs. It's denser and slightly drier due to being served cold. The frosting adds a pleasant sweetness, but the cookie itself is a standard sugar cookie, best enjoyed when allowed to warm up a bit.
Strawberry Pretzel Pie
The Strawberry Pretzel Pie cookie is new to the lineup. It features pretzel pieces, cream cheese topping, and strawberry jam. The base and topping both incorporate pretzel pieces, providing a mix of sweet and salty flavors. The strawberry jam tastes fresh, resembling Smuckers preserves, and the cream cheese adds a soft, marshmallow-like texture. This cookie is a standout, offering a perfect balance of flavors.
Carrot Cake
Lastly, the Carrot Cake cookie includes ingredients like cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, coconut, pineapple, and carrots. Topped with a light glaze, cream cheese frosting, and chopped pecans, it delivers a complex flavor profile. The spices, especially nutmeg and ginger, are prominent. The cake is moist and fluffy with a subtle carrot flavor. However, the frosting is not as sweet as traditional carrot cake frosting, making it a milder option.
Overall Impressions
- Most Sweet: Strawberry Pretzel Pie
- Least Sweet: Lemon Crinkle
- Personal Favorites: Strawberry Pretzel Pie and Double Fudge Brownie
The Strawberry Pretzel Pie stands out as the must-try cookie due to its unique blend of flavors and perfect sweetness. The Double Fudge Brownie is also highly recommended for chocolate lovers. The Lemon Crinkle offers a refreshing, less sweet option, and the Sugar Cookie is a solid choice for traditional cookie fans. The Carrot Cake, while less sweet, provides a delightful spice blend and a satisfying texture.
Conclusion
All cookies are worth trying, and the new additions, particularly the Strawberry Pretzel Pie, are impressive. Don't hesitate to experiment with these flavors, especially if you enjoy a mix of sweet and savory. Happy tasting!
No comments